Browse > Home / Archive: 03. June 2008

Who Would You Rather Have?

June 3, 2008

Brett Favre has retired — we think.

Who would you now put in the NFC QB pantheon? Let’s go division by division:

NFC East

  • Cowboys — Tony Romo
  • Giants — Eli Manning
  • Eagles — Donovan McNabb
  • Redskins — Jason Campbell

NFC North

  • Packers — Aaron Rogers
  • Bears — Rex Grossman
  • Vikings — Tarvaris Jackson/Kelly Holcombe?
  • Lions — Jon Kitna

NFC South

  • Bucs — Jeff Garcia
  • Saints — Drew Brees
  • Falcons — Matt Ryan
  • Panthers — Jake Delhomme

NFC West

  • Seahawks — Matt Hasselbeck
  • Rams — Marc Bulger
  • Cardinals — Kurt Warner/Matt Leinart
  • 49ers — Alex Smith

Who do you put in the top tier? I’d say Brees and Romo without hesitation. Manning’s regular season work doesn’t merit a mention but that stellar playoff run last year is what the game is all about.

What about McNabb and Hasselbeck, who have taken teams to Super Bowls and can still perform at top level with strong supporting casts? Or Bulger, who flies under the radar but is very effective when he has protection, which is rare these days?

Create a pantheon and a second tier in the thread.

Written by Rafael Vela · Filed Under News | 79 Comments 

DISCLAIMER: This site and its contents are for informational and amusement purposes only. This site is NOT officially sponsored by, nor endorsed by the Dallas Cowboys football organization, its players, coaches, staff, or the National Football League. Nothing written anywhere within this site is intended to be perceived as the site being so sponsored or endorsed. All original work, articles and comment posted by Rafael Vela, Raul Villaronga or invited guest bloggers, however, are protected by applicable copyright laws. Comments written by posters visiting the site are voluntarily submitted to stimulate discussion and debate without the expectation of copyright protection on the part of those visiting posters. It is not the responsibility of this site or its authors to enforce the copyright protection of such comments posted by visitors to this site. The authors cannot assume any liability for actions taken in reliance on these articles...that would be just silly and Don Meredith (who also does not officially sponsor nor endorse this site, but we love him anyway) well, he would just laugh at you. Thank you.

Your Dallas Cowboys Blue and Silver Report is Digg proof thanks to caching by WP Super Cache!